Your boss is yelled at for insubordination

Employment Law: Warning for naughty employees?

Can I actually issue a warning to an employee if he is unfriendly to me and his colleagues? Asks Manfred Schwieger.

Dear Mr. Schwieger,

Employees must always treat their superiors with a minimum of respect. Disrespectful behavior or disrespectful statements must therefore not be tolerated, as employees should exercise a so-called duty of consideration towards superiors and colleagues. If they do not adhere to this, employers can issue a warning. Unfortunately, employees do not always see that their behavior leaves something to be desired and that the warning is therefore legal. As in the case of an employee who went to the state labor court of Rhineland-Palatinate against his warning - and finally lost on appeal (3 Sa 150/11).

The boss is amazed

"The boss is amazed"

What is allowed, what is not? The Berlin labor lawyer Ulf Weigelt provides answers to user questions. Every week, every Wednesday, in the labor law column "Da is amazed the boss".

Write to us (please include your name and place of residence). We are happy and choose one question every week from all the problems we are asked and answer it here.

You can read all the episodes here.

Disclaimer of liability

Please note: The author assumes no liability for the topicality, correctness, completeness or quality of the answers and information provided, as well as the case law. Liability claims against the author relating to material or immaterial damage caused by the use or non-use of the information provided or by the use of incorrect or incomplete information are fundamentally excluded. All texts on this website are protected by copyright. The author within the meaning of the law on copyright and related rights (UrhG) is lawyer and specialist lawyer for labor law Ulf Weigelt, Choriner Straße 63, 10435 Berlin. Literal or analogous quotations are only legally permissible with the prior written approval of the author or with an explicit reference to the third-party authorship (reference in the sense of § 63 UrhG). Violations will be prosecuted.

BUY AS E-BOOK

The answers from specialist lawyer Ulf Weigelt are also available to you in clearly arranged form as e-books. Once downloaded, you can look up the labor law issues it contains on your electronic reader anytime, anywhere.

You can find an overview of our e-books here: www.zeit.de/ebooks.

You can find all of Ulf Weigelt's books here.

A manager was insulted several times by one of his employees (who was also the chairman of the works council). The employee once wished him a "shitty weekend", another time a "shitty weekend". Furthermore, he did not follow the instructions to use his own office for his works council work - and not that of the superior. The employer no longer accepted all of this and issued a warning.

The works council chairman sued the warning and wanted to see it removed from his personnel file. But the judges of the Rhineland-Palatinate state labor court also found his behavior to be unacceptable - and the warning issued to him was therefore justified. For one thing, superiors don't have to overlook disrespectful behavior. On the other hand, you can determine which rooms may be used for which purposes.

For your case: You neither have to nor should you accept disrespectful behavior from an employee. And as you can see, in the case of serious breaches of duty such as the desire to have a "shitty weekend", a warning is well justified.

Yours Ulf Weigelt